Madeleine Truter, Head of Legal at Excellerate JHI, reframes ESG for legal teams as a business advantage, not a box to tick.
Buildings account for 40% of South Africa’s energy use, yet 80% of property firms still treat ESG as a compliance checkbox – roughly the same level of enthusiasm most of us reserve for our annual dental check-ups. This disconnect isn’t just a missed opportunity; it’s a liability in a country where loadshedding has become more predictable than traffic on Winnie Mandela Drive.
As South Africa navigates its unique sustainability challenges – energy crises, water scarcity, and social inequality that’s written into our urban geography – property management sits at the nexus of problem and solution. From my Sandton office, I’ve witnessed both the resistance to and remarkable potential of ESG transformation in our sector.
Our ESG landscape bears little resemblance to Europe’s well-regulated markets. When your tenants’ primary concern is whether the lights will stay on long enough to complete a MS Teams call, “carbon neutrality by 2050” feels somewhat aspirational.
The National Environmental Management Act and Green Star SA certification provide regulatory frameworks, but it’s BBBEE that truly distinguishes South African ESG. While international counterparts focus exclusively on environmental metrics, our market recognizes that social transformation is inseparable from sustainability.
When major financial services tenants start requesting carbon emissions data during lease negotiations, you know the landscape has shifted. These requests now come from procurement teams, not sustainability departments – ESG has moved from the CSR report to the balance sheet. Property owners who aren’t prepared for these questions might as well post a “vacant space available” sign permanently.
Traditional leases treat sustainability like an awkward footnote. Property managers should advocate for standard agreements that include energy efficiency targets, water conservation commitments, and waste reduction protocols – with tangible benefits for compliant tenants.
Consider implementing a tiered rental discount structure tied to sustainability KPIs. When I suggest this to landlords, their finance departments typically respond as if I’ve recommended they start paying rent to their tenants. But the potential benefits are compelling: properties with such arrangements could see up to 30% reduction in energy consumption and significantly improved tenant retention. Turns out people like saving money and the planet simultaneously – arguably in that order.
For property owners considering rooftop solar, prepare yourself – it requires the patience of a saint and the persistence of a toddler asking “why?” While regulations have eased, the process remains more complex than maintaining one’s composure at a gallery opening where your ex-boyfriend arrives with both his new wife and your former interior designer.
Landlords should explore embedded generation partnerships that could potentially bring their properties to 70% renewable energy usage. Yes, the approval process will require more signatures than a prenuptial agreement for a fourth marriage to a man with assets in three countries but imagine the selling proposition: 25% reduction in energy costs and uninterrupted power during loadshedding. In today’s market, that’s not just a nice-to-have – it’s the difference between signing a tenant and watching them choose the building across the street with backup power.
BBBEE compliance in property management often defaults to ownership structures while overlooking operational opportunities. Property owners should consider developing procurement frameworks that prioritize local suppliers and SMMEs, creating economic ecosystems around their properties.
Imagine a retail centre with a vendor development program that incubates local businesses to become suppliers. This isn’t charity; it is strategic relationship building. Local suppliers tend to show up during emergencies when national contractors put you on hold long enough to memorize their entire music playlist. Advise your landlords that community integration isn’t just good citizenship – it’s good business when the pipes burst at 2 AM.
“Legal teams must reposition themselves from risk managers to opportunity creators.”
Legal teams must help property owners balance marketing’s enthusiasm with documented reality. When an asset management team wants to brand a property as “South Africa’s greenest building,” suggest they might want metrics beyond “we have real plants in the lobby” to support the claim. Advise them that initial disappointment over marketing constraints can lead to a comprehensive certification strategy that ultimately delivers genuine market differentiation.
Climate risk assessment is no longer optional. Advise property owners to stress-test their assets against both physical risks (floods, extreme heat) and transition risks (carbon taxes, changing regulations). Warn development teams that waterfront properties might take on a more literal meaning as sea levels rise, though they’ll likely remain more concerned about next quarter’s occupancy rates.
Consider a typical struggling property in today’s market: a deteriorating office building with vacancy rates higher than a giraffe’s eye-level and energy efficiency lower than most people’s interest in reading the terms and conditions before clicking “I agree”.
Rather than advising owners to invest in minor greenwashing, property managers should recommend these comprehensive interventions:
The potential results? Properties implementing such strategies could see occupancy jump to 90%, operating costs fall by 30% and potentially command a 20% premium on rental rates. The transformation doesn’t come from following a global ESG template, but from addressing specifically South African challenges with locally relevant solutions.
As prop tech transforms buildings into data centres with walls, legal teams must navigate new complexities. When tenants ask if occupancy sensors can identify individual employees, property managers must explain that while POPIA will generally prohibit such surveillance, employees with distinctive fashion choices might be recognizable regardless.
Circular economy principles are reshaping construction and waste management practices. Property managers should recommend waste separation requirements for commercial tenants – these will initially receive the same enthusiastic reception as a traffic fine but could potentially divert up to 65% of waste from landfills.
Most significantly, ESG financing is revolutionizing property economics. Advise property owners about green bonds and sustainability-linked loans that offer preferential rates for qualifying projects. When first suggesting this to a CFO, expect them to look at you as if you’ve proposed accepting payment in cryptocurrency and organic vegetables.
ESG cannot remain a compliance afterthought delegated to a sustainability consultant hired for audit season. Legal teams must reposition themselves from risk managers to opportunity creators.
This starts with executive engagement. Recommend linking bonuses to sustainability outcomes – it tends to focus attention more effectively than inspirational posters in the break room.
Cross-functional ESG committees with legal leadership ensure cohesive implementation. When facilities management, leasing, tenant relations, and legal align around sustainability goals, we avoid the “sustainability said yes but legal said no” syndrome that plagues many organizations.
South Africa’s property sector faces unique challenges that global ESG frameworks don’t fully address. Our energy crisis demands innovation beyond the typical green building playbook. Our social context requires equity considerations that European models often overlook.
By integrating ESG into core property management strategies, we transform compliance obligations into competitive advantages. The question isn’t whether your property portfolio will adapt to sustainability demands, but whether it will do so reactively or strategically.
As for me, I’ve updated my job description from “the person who says no to keep us out of trouble” to “the person who finds yes within compliant frameworks.” And yes, I keep emergency chocolate in my desk drawer – navigating the ESG transformation of South Africa’s property sector requires sustenance, preferably fair trade and locally sourced.
Be part of a growing global community committed to advancing in-house legal leadership.
Alexander Shevchenko, Chief Legal Officer at WEB PAY, shares a practical framework for dissenting with influence. He outlines how GCs and senior in-house lawyers can...
Learn more about When and how to disagree with bosses or other influential people at work?
Aleksandra Polak, Assistant General Counsel at Billtrust in USA, explores how modern in-house teams can outperform law firms not by working harder, but by working...
Learn more about Faster and more expert than law firms: the new playbook for in-house legal
Head of Legal
Excellerate JHI
South Africa